The Clash Between the Supreme Court and Electoral Bonds - Unraveling the Transparency Dilemma

-


In a groundbreaking decision on February 15, 2024, the Supreme Court of India declared the Electoral Bond scheme unconstitutional. Initiated in 2017, this scheme permitted anonymous donations to political parties through the acquisition of electoral bonds from designated banks, primarily the State Bank of India (SBI).

The verdict, delivered by a five-judge Constitution Bench, was a response to petitions challenging the scheme's lack of transparency, with critics contending that anonymous political funding breeds corruption and erodes democratic accountability.

The Heart of the Matter

Primary concerns surrounding electoral bonds included:

Opacity 

Donors remained anonymous, impeding public scrutiny of political party funding.

Imbalanced Field

Smaller parties with limited fundraising capabilities potentially faced disadvantages compared to their larger counterparts.

Risk of Misuse 

Anonymity could facilitate money laundering and the influence of undisclosed interests.

Supreme Court's Rationale

The Court underscored several points in its judgment:

Right to Information Violation Deeming anonymity a violation of citizens' fundamental right to information under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.

Electoral Process Threat 

Expressing concern that anonymous funding could unduly influence political parties and compromise the fairness of elections.

Insufficient Safeguards

 Existing measures against misuse of electoral bonds were considered inadequate.

SBI's Role and the Escalating Dispute

The Court instructed the Election Commission of India (ECI) to receive details of each electoral bond encashed by political parties within three weeks. However, the SBI, responsible for issuing the bonds, sparked fresh controversy.

Disclosure Delay 

Despite the Court's set deadline, the SBI sought an extension until June 30, 2024, raising questions about the bank's commitment to transparency.

Looking Forward

The Supreme Court's verdict and the subsequent actions by the SBI have ignited a national debate:

Will the Court grant an extension to the SBI?

How will the ECI enforce the disclosure mandate on political parties?

Is a legislative response imminent following the Court's judgment?

Towards Transparency

While the Supreme Court's decision marks a crucial stride toward political funding transparency, effective implementation is essential for a levelled playing field and preventing potential misuse.

Citizen awareness and sustained scrutiny of political party funding practices remain pivotal for upholding a healthy democracy.

Stay updated for further developments on this unfolding narrative. 

Share your thoughts in the comments below! Do you advocate for stricter regulations on political funding in India?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Situation in Manipur: A Crisis in the Making

-
The Situation in Manipur: A Crisis in the Making The northeastern Indian state of Manipur has been rocked by violence in recent months, with over 100 deaths with over 400 wounded and the burning of at least 1,700 buildings. The violence has been sparked by inter-ethnic clashes between the Meitei and Kuki communities, two of the largest ethnic groups in the state. Nearly 60,000 people have been displaced and taken shelter in some 350 camps. Some 40,000 security forces- army soldiers, paramilitaries, police-are struggling to quell the violence. Only a quarter of the more than 40,000 weapons looted by mobs from police armouries have been voluntarily returned since the violence began. More than 200 churches and 17 temples have been destroyed or damaged by mobs. Homes of local ministers and legislators have been attacked and set on fire.Normal life has been strangled: a night curfew continues in most of the 16 districts; schools are shut and internet services have been suspended. A main hig
Read more

Recent By-Election Upset: Opposition Gains Momentum

-
The latest by-election results in India have provided a significant boost to the opposition parties, igniting hopes of a substantial challenge to the reigning Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in the forthcoming 2024 general election. On September 5, 2023, the opposition clinched four seats in the by-elections, while the BJP secured three. Notably, these victories for the opposition occurred in states where the BJP currently holds power, including Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand, and Kerala. These by-election outcomes underscore growing dissatisfaction with the BJP's performance, mainly due to criticisms regarding its management of the economy, handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, restoration of old pension System and response to the farmers' protests. The opposition parties are now eager to capitalize on this discontent as they gear up for the upcoming general election. Their strategy is likely to revolve around addressing critical issues such as the economy, inflation, and unemployment. Th
Read more

समा चकेवा पर्व: भाई-बहन के प्रेम का प्रतीक

-
  समा चकेवा हिंदू धर्म का एक महत्वपूर्ण पर्व है जो हर साल कार्तिक पूर्णिमा के दिन मनाया जाता है। यह पर्व समृद्धि, खुशहाली और शांति की कामना करता है। इस दिन, लोग स्नान, पूजा-अर्चना और दान-पुण्य करते हैं। समा चकेवा का इतिहास बहुत पुराना है। कहा जाता है कि यह पर्व भगवान विष्णु के अवतार भगवान राम के जन्म के अवसर पर मनाया जाता है। भगवान राम के जन्म के बाद, उनकी मां कौशल्या ने उन्हें स्नान कराया और फिर उन्हें पूजा-अर्चना के बाद दान-पुण्य दिया। इसी दिन से, समा चकेवा पर्व मनाया जाने लगा। समा चकेवा का आध्यात्मिक महत्व बहुत अधिक है। इस दिन, लोग स्नान करके अपने शरीर और मन को शुद्ध करते हैं। पूजा-अर्चना करके, वे भगवान से आशीर्वाद मांगते हैं। दान-पुण्य करके, वे दूसरों की मदद करते हैं। समा चकेवा का सामाजिक महत्व भी बहुत अधिक है। इस दिन, लोग एक-दूसरे के घर जाकर मिलते हैं और उन्हें बधाई देते हैं। इस तरह, यह पर्व लोगों के बीच प्रेम और भाईचारे को बढ़ावा देता है। समा चकेवा की परंपराएं समा चकेवा के दिन, लोग सुबह जल्दी उठकर स्नान करते हैं। फिर, वे मंदिर जाकर भगवान की पूजा-अर्चना करते हैं। पूजा
Read more